Showing posts with label Trinity Sunday. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Trinity Sunday. Show all posts

Sunday, June 19, 2011

Symbols of the Faith

This sermon was heard at the First Presbyterian Church in Marshall, Texas on Sunday June 19, 2011, Trinity Sunday.


Genesis 1:1-2:4a
Psalm 8
2Corinthians 13:11-13
Matthew 28:16-20

May the words of my mouth and the meditations of our hearts be acceptable to you, O Lord, our rock and our redeemer.  Amen

Marie and I went to the Christian store in Longview last week to get Lea and Jerry’s wedding present. While there, I found a couple of neat things at the cash register. Ah, the joys of retail, put it near the cash register and let the impulse buying begin.

What I found were these things, they are a color coded ways to explain the Christian faith. They explain the faith using several concepts with a different color for each. This is the “God’s Plan for Salvation: Bookmark.” On it, sin is represented by the color black; the blood of Christ is red; faith is blue; forgiveness is white; life is green; and heaven is gold.  With each of these colors and concepts there is a scriptural verse.

The other one is called “Colors of THE WORD, A Wordless Book.” On it, sin and the blood are still black and red, but after that it gets different. With this one, white stands for purity and blue stands for baptism. The green and yellow are almost the same. Where green stands for life on the bookmark, on the Wordless Book it stands for new life in the other. Where the yellow means heaven on the one, on the other it represents living forever. I guess if you want to say that there’s no real difference between the green and the yellow I wouldn’t disagree with you. But it makes me wonder whether their respective designers would agree that it’s just splitting hairs.

These tools are given to the people of God as symbols of the faith. These are two ways to tell the story of God, the story of salvation, using colors instead of words.

Symbols are used extensively to help us understand and explain the faith. Our most common symbol is the cross. You’ll notice that in Protestant churches the cross is empty. The body remains on the symbol we call a crucifix. Neither the crucifix nor the cross can be a witness to Christian faith without the other, but the differences between these symbols point to the differences between the Roman, Orthodox, and Reformed churches.

The importance of these symbols to these faiths is tremendous. The crucifix points to the ultimate sacrifice of the Passion of the Christ. The empty cross’ distinction is that it certainly points to the death of the Christ, and even more it points to the resurrection and that death cannot contain God. Artistically it’s one small distinction, theologically it’s tremendous. The difference lands us on different sides of Good Friday, Easter, and the Reformation.

It’s like the two different color coded gospel things; they’re quite similar, but the differences make them distinctive.

The Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) symbol is a cross with its own distinctive elements. Of course it is a cross that points toward the death and resurrection, but on either side of this cross are flames which represent the Pentecost. When you look at the stylized elements of the cross you can find a bird sweeping down from above toward the crossbar which represents the Holy Spirit and the Baptism of the Lord. Below the bird itself is a pulpit that represents worship and the Word of God proclaimed in the church. The crossbar itself is a book that represents Holy Scripture.

Within the dove is a fish, the symbol of God’s plenty from the feeding of the multitudes. The fish was also the earliest symbol of the Church as a worshiping body. In the middle of the pulpit to the spine of the book is a cup representing the Lord’s Supper. Finally, the weakest of the symbols in the PC (U.S.A.) seal is the invisible lines that form a triangle from the tip of the bird’s beak to either side of the flames connecting along the base of the symbol. This three sided shape represents the Trinity.

Of course it might be appropriate that symbol of the Trinity, arguably the most cryptic symbol of basic theology, is the weakest and least obviously definable piece of the denomination’s seal.

I always have trouble getting a handle on Trinity Sunday, especially since our gospel reading, the Great Commission, is perhaps the most evangelistic reading in the Gospel. Celebrating Trinity Sunday with Father’s Day adds its own quirks. So on this Trinity Sunday, what do we say about the Trinity? On this Father’s Day, what do we say about the Father?

Let’s begin here; the word “Trinity” is not found in scripture. It’s a theological term. It’s a way people describe God based on the witness of scripture. One of my theological dictionaries calls the Trinity “The coexistence of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit in the unity of the Godhead. While not a biblical term, ‘trinity’ represents the crystallization of New Testament teaching.”[1] That’s as good as any place to start.

The trinitarian formula used most frequently in worship, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, is found in scripture. It was in today’s readings from 2Corinthians and Matthew. In 2Corinthians it is a blessing, a benediction to benefit the recipient. As we prepare to leave the sanctuary, I use this same benediction. In Matthew, it is used to describe the one God in three Persons we worship as we welcome new members into the community in the waters of baptism.

Of course, this formula is not without its critics. As humanity has explored the diverse possibilities for trinitarian images, there is a temptation to try to bring the mystery of God under our control.[2]

Some say it is gender specific; too male, not enough female.  Even though in the Westminster Confession we declare the First Person of the Trinity is a most pure spirit without body, parts, or passions;[3] people get touchy about the maleness or femaleness of God. The quantity of masculine words to identify God in scripture only adds to the controversy.

Others note that people whose fathers weren’t present or were abusive have difficulty seeing God as the figure of a good Father, father with a capital “F.”  On Father’s Day, this is particularly poignant. I can’t disagree with this, after all, earthly fathers are a sin-soaked people; just like everyone else.  But unfortunately, our earthly perceptions of fathers infect our perception of God the Father who we confess is infinite in being and perfection.[4]

Another issue with the history and theology of the Trinity is that some considered Jesus the Christ and the Holy Spirit to be secondary deities, subordinate to the First Person of the Trinity.  But the church affirms that Jesus and the Spirit are not some lackey or servant gods to a supposedly supreme God when in truth all three persons of God are equal to one another.

Additionally, some have renamed the persons of the Trinity based on what we think are their usual roles.  The most common of these is “Creator, Redeemer, and Sustainer.”  This isn’t good because it tries to cubby-hole the works of God into a specific person of God.  This is not the nature of the Triune God.   For example, our Genesis passage this morning speaks directly to the Spirit’s role in creation as the wind that swept across the face of the waters.  Our Psalm sings of God the Great I AM as the one who protects and sustains us. 

All three persons of God create, redeem, sustain, and so much more.  We need to remember that naming the Triune God by roles hides the truth of the scriptural witness and the nature of the fullness of God. 

Our human efforts to tame the names of God have helped humanity homogenize God into compartments based on our perceptions of what God does.  It has helped us put God into a hierarchy that would make a business tycoon proud.  It has helped us infect the glory of God by our individual perceptions.  By speaking of the Three Persons of God in these ways, in a very human way, we limit God.  But the Triune God is not contained by human frailty. 

Five years ago, the General Assembly voted to accept a report on this issue called “The Trinity: God’s Love Overflowing.”[5] It included this great truth: “Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit are, together with God the Father, fully and eternally God.  As the Nicene Creed affirms, Jesus Christ is ‘God from God, Light from Light, true God from true God,’ and the Holy Spirit is to be worshiped and glorified as ‘the Lord, the giver of life.’”[6]

All three persons of the Triune God are eternal and equal.  As the Triune God, the three persons cannot be separated from one another yet they are distinct from one another. 

Now, if you think this is beginning to sound more like three Gods than one God in three persons, I can’t blame you.  Perhaps one of the most important things we can say about the Trinity is that the concept of “Trinity” is a model, a way of explaining the mystery of God. 

The PC (U.S.A.) Trinity Report puts it this way, “The mystery of the Trinity is an open and radiant mystery.  It is the mystery of the truth that God is holy, abundant, overflowing love both in relationship with us and in all eternity.  We meet God’s threefold love in astonishing faithfulness of the Holy One of Israel, in the costly grace given to us in Jesus Christ our Savior, and in the new life in communion with God and others that has come to us in the gift of the Holy Spirit.”[7]

The best way I have found of describing how to imagine the Trinity comes from the Swiss theologian Karl Barth who said “in [the Trinity] we are speaking not of three divine I’s, but thrice of the one divine I.”[8]  There is one divine presence who has been shown to us in three distinct persons, shown to us in scripture, and still being shown to us today by grace.  God in three persons is diverse, and in one, the Triune God is united.

The question becomes “What do we do with this knowledge?” The answer is found in our gospel reading, we follow the Great Commission.

The Great Commission tells the church to, go and make disciples. It even tells us how to go and make disciples, by baptizing and teaching. But what shall we teach? I’m pretty sure none of us want to teach people the symbols of the faith using this Trinity-weekend-seminar-jammed-into-seven-minutes I’ve just given you. But there are other symbols.

Today’s Children’s sermon is a great example, by connecting Father’s Day and our Heavenly Father, Al taught the children about who God is. Honestly, because of time restraints and trying to teach kids and youth from Pre-Kindergarten through Junior High; Children sermons are great examples of what and how we should teach.

We have a symbol of the faith we share in the simplest of crosses. We teach that the instrument of the most degrading death the Roman Empire could inflict on another person is the empty threat death has on our lives. The cross is empty; God in Christ has defeated death.

We even have the symbol of the creation story from Genesis 1 that we read today. This story is rich in symbols and symmetry. This story, never meant to be a scientific description of creation, still contains more truth than facts can ever portray. It’s a story that links the creation of our cosmos with the creation of life, all under the gaze of the ever watchful Spirit of God.

The love of the Triune God overflows from the relationship of the three persons.  We were created to share in that love, that glory, that joy.  We can’t repay God for the love we are shown; so what we must do, all we can do, is love in return and share God’s love.  Love God and love one another in word and in deed. This is what we can surely teach. In sharing God’s overflowing love we baptize not with water, but with the love of the Triune God.

This is a daunting command, but with this command we are given the assurance that Jesus, the Son of God and the Son of Man, will be with us to the end of the age.  Rely on this and rely on the overflowing love in the fullness of the Triune God Almighty, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

[1] “Trinity,” Interpreter’s Dictionary of the Bible
[2] Office of Theology and Worship, PC(USA), “The Trinity: God’s Love Overflowing.”  PC(USA): Louisville, KY, 2004,, lines 354-355
[3] Westminster Confession of Faith, Chapter II, Paragraph 1. In the PC(USA) Book of Confessions this is found at 6.011.
[4] Ibid.
[5] Note that I wrote “accepted” and not “approved.”  Because of the controversial nature of this report the General Assembly of the PC(USA) did not approve this report but instead voted to accept it.
[6] Ibid, Office of Theology and Worship, lines 217-220.
[7] Ibid. lines 245-249.
[8] Barth, Karl, “Church Dogmatics.”  Volume I.1.Edinburgh: T & & Clark, 1975, page 351

Sunday, May 30, 2010

What Is Truth?

This sermon was heard at the First Presbyterian Church in Berryville, Arkansas on Sunday May 30, 2010, Trinity Sunday. Nineteen footnotes is excessive, but some of the notes are comments for readers that I did not make from the pulpit. What is in parentheses was spoken.

Proverbs 8:1-4, 22-31
Psalm 8
Romans 5:1-5
John 16:12-15

May the words of my mouth and the meditations of our hearts be acceptable to you, O Lord, our rock and our redeemer. Amen.

Several years ago, the Comedy Central cable channel premiered “The Colbert Report.” No, not Colbert, like Jim the golfer, but Colbert—with a French pronunciation. In an interview with Bill O’Reilly on The Factor, Colbert stated that he is of “Irish descent and only adopted the French pronunciation of his surname to ‘get the cultural elites’ on his side.”[1] Pronounced this way, the name of the show rhymes; it’s “The Colbert Report,” not “The Colbert Report.” What’s funny about that is…[2] never mind, it’s the cornerstone joke of this satiric farce.

In the premier episode, Colbert introduced a feature segment that would define his show called “The Wørd” where the host takes a common, or not so common, word or phrase and defines it in novel and hilarious ways. The first word to enter the lexicon was "truthiness."

Truthiness is defined as “‘truth’ that a person claims to know intuitively ‘from the gut’ without regard to evidence, logic, intellectual examination, or facts.[3] Webster's has sanctioned truthiness with two definitions: “truth that comes from the gut, not books” and “the quality of preferring concepts or facts one wishes to be true, rather than concepts of facts known to be true.”[4]

In a BBC editorial,[5] Drew Westen cites the first debate of the 2000 Presidential campaign as an example illustrating the perils of trying to persuade voters with truth verses truthiness. In the debate, Vice President Al Gore explained how Governor George W. Bush’s health care plan would be more expensive to persons on Medicare including the worst phrase ever used in a political debate. Vice President Gore said, “Under the governor’s plan, if you kept the same fee for service that you have now under Medicare, your premiums would go up by between 18% and 47%, and that is the study of the Congressional plan that he’s modeled his proposal on by the Medicare actuaries.”

Medicare actuaries? Mr. Gore, you had me at (insert snoring sound here).[6] Muddled would be more like it to most debate watchers.

With this response: “Look, this is a man who has great numbers. He talks about numbers. I’m beginning to think not only did he invent the internet, but he invented the calculator. It’s fuzzy math. It’s trying to scare people in the voting booth.” Mr. Bush established himself to be one of us, not one of them; one of those Harvard educated cultural elites.[7]

The Vice President talked numbers and policy. The Governor countered with stories of what would happen “to you.” Westen points out that “stories always trump statistics, which means the politician with the best stories is going to win.” It’s little wonder the nation elected President Bush instead of President Gore.[8]

Stories over facts, anecdotes over data, gut feelings over measured research; this is the essence of truthiness. But heaven forbid; truthiness and being a follower of our Lord and Messiah do not mix well.

On this day, on this Trinity Sunday, the disciples are told “When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide [them] into all the truth.” The disciples are told that the Spirit will hear the truth from the Father; this truth will glorify the Son. The disciples are then told again that the Father has given all truth to the Son; and this truth he will share with the Spirit who will share it with them.

The Holy Spirit of God, the Spirit who was at the creation of all that was created, the Spirit who descended upon Jesus like a dove, the Spirit that roared through the house where the disciples were staying on that first Christian Pentecost; the Holy Spirit of God is the Spirit of truth.
So here’s a good question for us: “What is truth?”

It’s a good question, deceptively good. Pilate asked Jesus this question. We read that passage from John’s gospel every year, every Good Friday. And considering that the 117th meeting of the Presbytery of Arkansas is coming up next weekend, the Session meets with the General Presbyter the next day, and the 219th General Assembly meets in July, it’s a darn fine question. These church leaders meet to do the church’s work in the name of the Lord. So again I ask: “What is truth?”

Being the stickler that I am, I start with what truth meant for the people who heard these words from the lips of Jesus. In the Hebraic understanding, truth is firm, solid, valid, and binding. When it is applied to people, and we do say that the Holy Spirit is a person, it characterizes their speech, action, and thought. It describes someone with integrity.[9]

In the Jewish legal sense, it means that the truth rests upon authentic facts. Truth is factual, impressive. It is beyond trivial objections. It is undisputable.[10] I guess that’s the Al Gore sense of truth. Of course in ancient Israel, the Rabbis were the arbiters of God’s truth, and they saw the Torah as its ultimate expression. By this truth, they found evidence of the Living God and that God is the everlasting king.[11]

Of course, legal truth is not the same as religious truth. Truth goes beyond legalistic definitions making it a mark and goal of divine action. Because of this truth, God is worthy of absolute confidence.

To those who wrote Hebraic law, truth has an element of transparency; it carries a meaning of not concealing. Truth declares itself that it really is the truth. (By the way, my English teacher always told me not to use the word while defining the word. Then again, this definition comes from the Greek, not the English. Let’s go on.) Of course, there is an implication that people might try to conceal, falsify, truncate, or suppress; of course that’s the nature of sin. So truth must encompass the full most real state of affairs.

In legal affairs, this is the difference between “the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth” and “don’t give more answer than the question asks.” The truth demands the whole truth. Lawyers and their ancient counterparts don’t want anymore truth than is necessary.

Truth has certainty of force. It has judicial righteousness. People on whom you can rely are people of truth. It denotes a sincerity and honesty that like any virtue is public, not private. Truth is an authentic teaching of faith, something that I have endeavored over the past five years behind this pulpit. The truth has the ability to show the full difference between the divine and what isn’t divine.[12]

My English language bible dictionary elaborates on truth. It says that biblical people who spoke the truth often used metaphors, expressions to tell the truth of the glory of God. They had to do this because the realities of the truth were too difficult to express and be understood in literal language.[13] Maybe this is what Jesus meant when he said the disciples could not bear to hear the truth at that moment. I’m just guessing here.

It also says that truth is defined by a pattern of action. Truth is not established in a one-off sort of experience. It must be continuously told, it must be continuously lived. It is a characteristic of our actions, not our words. By this definition we cannot tell the truth without living the truth. Since actions speak louder than words, “do as I say, not as I do” is not an option.

In teaching, truth is teaching reality, not myth to the listener. It teaches reliability of the message as a guide for life. It recalls the Jewish characteristic of reliable teaching as truth and as another way of expressing what is held dear in the Torah, in the Law.[14]

John’s writings take all this and wonderfully distills it saying that truth is God’s faithful commitment to God’s people. This is where we get into one of the most glorious answers to the question of “What is truth?” John’s gospel teaches that “the incarnate Word makes God’s truth accessible in the sense that Jesus displays the reality of the divine person. Jesus is at once the manifestation of God’s faithful character and the divine reality.”[15]

Now we are getting to where the rubber meets the road. Pardon me for backing up into my opening story, but I am about to introduce a grain of truthiness into worship this morning. I thank you for your rapt attention to my excursion into the dictionary answers to the question “what is truth?” I don’t blame you if your eyes glazed over either, even if just a little bit, as I entered into the hallowed ground of my “inner Al Gore.”

If truthiness has taught me one thing it’s that all of the facts in the world don’t matter when something more powerful is at stake. I can give you all of the facts about truth in the world, but it is the stories resonate more than the data ever will.

R. Buckminster Fuller teaches “Truth is completely spontaneous. Lies have to be taught.”[16]

William Sloane Coffin has written “Fear distorts truth, not by exaggerating the ills of the world… but by underestimating our ability to deal with them… while love seeks truth, fear seeks safety.”[17]

Acting in truth is the focus of this expression from Mennonite writer John K. Stoner: “Speaking the truth is the most significant political action available to any of us—not voting, but speaking the truth. This view is based on the familiar biblical notion that the Word is central. The Word is the truth; the expression of the truth by human lips moves culture and history toward the government of God. There is no higher form of political action, nor is there one that can contribute more to the wholeness of the human community.”[18]

In their own way, in their own incomplete way, there is an element of truthiness in all of these examples, but I will admit, they do give us a bit of traction into the question “what is truth?” that straight data lacks. So let us turn from truth that is not quite the truth and move to that most basic source of truth, scripture.

Let us return to Jesus’ long teaching during his final meal with his disciples, the lessons he gives the eleven remaining disciples during his last supper. Our reading today comes from this speech, also in this teaching is John 14 where Jesus tells his disciples “I am the truth.” This is our answer, Jesus is the truth. Jesus is the truth.

Still, there is something devilish about thinking that we have fully received the whole truth. It’s not that the truth ever changes; it’s that our understanding of the truth does. This is what it means to be reformed and continually being reformed. “When we claim to have arrived at the Truth, capital T, we cheat ourselves. Finality of understanding, closure of interpretation, shuts us off from further insights, illuminations, inspirations, and so on. When it comes to Truth with a capital T, we spend our lives in waiting rooms on our knees. There are no ‘immaculate perceptions.’ We all walk into the dark.”[19]

Yes Jesus is the truth, and if we think that in our lifetime, with scripture, with 2,000 years of interpretation of the New Testament and 2,000 more of the Old, and even with the gift of the Holy Spirit—the Spirit of Truth indwelling us since that first Pentecost, we will never know the whole truth. The truth is just too big to be known by us, that is the mystery of the Triune God.

The answer to the question what is truth is often in front of us. It calls us to know the truth that we are saved by grace through faith. It calls us to act with the integrity of Jesus in all situations so that our actions will glorify the Son as the Spirit glorifies the Son; not to earn our salvation, but to respond to it. It calls us to act in truth humbly, because Jesus was humble.

So let the answer to the question of what is truth mean one thing to all of us. Let the answer mean that all spiritual truth in the world is nothing if we do nothing with it. We must remember the ancient Hebrew definition that truth is in action and the teaching of Stoner that the Word spoken is central. Virtue requires public action, there is no such thing as a private virtue.

Seek truth, act in truth. Remember love seeks truth, fear seeks safety. Jesus is the truth, as lavishly bold as a flash of lightening and as sublimely humble as the distant rumble of thunder.

[1] Stephen Colbert (character), http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Colbert_(character), citing “Stephen Colbert Enters the No Spin Zone”, http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,244882,00.html, retrieved May 28, 2010.
[2] Homage to the Reverend James “Skipper” French.
[3] Truthiness, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truthiness, retrieved May 28, 2010.
[4] The Truth of Truthiness, http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2006/12/12/opinion/meyer/main2250923.shtml, retrieved May 28, 2010.
[5] BBC News, “Why Do People Vote Against Their Own Interests?” http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8474611.stm, retrieved May 28, 2010.
[6] Yes, it’s a “Jerry Maguire” reference.
[7] This is where I mention that George W. Bush went to Yale University and was a member of one of its most famous secret societies, Skull and Bones, but does anybody say that Bush was an Ivy Leaguer just like Gore, nooooooo.
[8] Please, don’t get started on popular vote vs. Electoral College, I get it, I get it. So as a registered Democrat, let me just say for the record that the 43rd President of the United States is George W. Bush, not Al Gore, Jr.
[9] Kittel, Gerhard, “Theological Dictionary of the New Testament.” Volume I. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 1964, pages 232-233.
[10] Ibid. 233.
[11] Ibid. 237.
[12] Ibid. 242-245
[13] Truth, “New Interpreter’s Dictionary of the Bible.” Volume 5 Nashville, TN: Abingdon Press, 2009, Page 675
[14] Ibid.
[15] Ibid.
[16] HomileticsOnline.com, keyword search “Truth”, http://homileticsonline.com/subscriber/illustration_search.asp?item_topic_id=859, retrieved May 28, 2010
[17] Coffin, William Sloane, “The Courage to Love.” New York: Harper and Row, 1982, 60.
[18] Stoner, John K. in “Mennonite Life.” quoted in The Other Side, March-April 1997 and in Context, August 15, 1997, 4.
[19] Ibid.

Sunday, June 07, 2009

Wordplay

This sermon was heard at the First Presbyterian Church in Berryville, Arkansas on Sunday June 7, 2009, Trinity Sunday.

Isaiah 6:1-8
Psalm 29
Romans 8:12-17
John 3:1-17

May the words of my mouth and the meditations of our hearts be acceptable to you, O Lord, our rock and our redeemer. Amen

In 1981, Kurt Vonnegut published a sermon called Palm Sunday. One of the points he makes is that any joke translated out of its native language is doomed. He goes as far to say that any joke told in the King James English is doomed to sound like Charlton Heston. Reading this week’s gospel lesson I am inclined to agree. Admittedly, the New Revised Standard translation does not sound much like Charlton Heston, but it isn’t Larry the Cable Guy either. Lost in the translation of this text are some well crafted puns.

The first pun Jesus shares with Nicodemus is found in verse three. Ordinarily, this is translated “no one can see the kingdom of God unless he is born again.” This is the translation found in the New King James, the Revised Standard, and the New International Versions. The majority of translations read like this, but not the New Revised Standard Version. The NRSV says, “no one can see the kingdom of God without being born from above.” How in the world do hundreds of years of translation move us from “again” to “from above?”

In a metaphysical, theological conversation, we might be able, after some contention, to concur that these readings can be equivalent, in a broad philosophical sense. In a broad way, the “again” of traditional translation can lead us to say that this rebirth comes “from above.” Frankly, this sort of argument sounds like the sort of thing philosophers talk about after cocktails during a soiree at a conference. Honestly though, this isn’t very funny and I promised you a pun.

There’s an easy explanation really; the Greek word used can either mean “again” or “from above.” It’s kind of boring, isn’t it? It’s just a translation thing. But did Jesus mean: “again” or “from above?” The Greek word used here is found five times in John’s gospel, and only in this instance is it ever translated as “again.” Every other time this word appears in John’s gospel, it is translated “from above.” So by the “majority rules” school of linguistics, we should say “from above” instead of “again” in all of these cases. Also, there is another Greek word for “again” which is used in John’s gospel. So with consistency in mind, it would make sense that if John had meant to say “again” here, the other word would have been used.

But here’s the joke… Perhaps Jesus wanted Nicodemus to consider both “again” and “from above.” What does it mean to be born “again?” What does it mean to be born “from above?” I like to think that Jesus was using the pun here. Perhaps he meant both. We must be born again—from above. Jesus uses a bit of wordplay to force Nicodemus out of not one, but two comfort zones. To be born again and born from above must have been unnerving for the Pharisee. Nicodemus even asks “how can a man be born after growing old?” Jesus answers Nicodemus by talking about birth in the Spirit, as well as from the womb.

The second pun is found in verse eight. Jesus tells Nicodemus that “the wind blows where it chooses and you do not know where it comes from or where it goes. So it is with everyone who is born of the Spirit.” Here again, the pun gets lost in the translation. The word for wind and Spirit are the same. Everywhere in scripture you find the words wind and spirit, they come from the same ancient Greek or Hebrew word. So everyone who is born in the Spirit is moved by a force that we can neither see nor discern. We are also not able to discern where the wind will take us.

The third pun is found in verse fourteen, “And just as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, so must the Son of Man be lifted up.” This pun is easier to find in English. The Old Testament reference about Moses and the serpent is found in Numbers 21. Here, the Lord gives Israel victory over the Canaanites. Israel promptly offers thanks to the Lord by complaining about food and water.

So the Lord sends a brood of vipers to bite the people. Some even die. The people promptly recognize the error of their ways. “‘We have sinned by speaking against the LORD and against you [Moses]; pray to the LORD to take away the serpents from us.’ So Moses prayed for the people. And the LORD said to Moses, ‘Make a poisonous serpent, and set it on a pole; and everyone who is bitten shall look at it and live.’”[1] Moses did this, he lifted a bronze serpent upon a pole and all who saw it were revived.

When we read that the Son of Man must be lifted up, often (and rightly) we think that he must be exalted. And this will come to pass in John’s gospel; Jesus will be lifted up by his Father after his resurrection and glorious ascension. He will be lifted as our Lord and Messiah first by Peter, then by the apostles and disciples and we continue to lift, to exalt, the name of Jesus. The Lord God even lifts Jesus during his baptism and the transfiguration.

Jesus will be lifted up, just as the serpent was lifted up—upon a pole, upon a tree, upon the cross. And just as all who saw the snake lifted up upon the pole were healed, all who know the sacrifice Jesus made on behalf of all creation are made whole and participate in the healing of creation. Jesus was lifted up, Jesus is exalted.

One of the truths of translation is that every translation is also an interpretation. Beginning with the Latin of the early Roman church and moving into the English translations authorized by King James and beyond, every time the bible is translated, it is also interpreted for a different society and culture. This is unavoidable. It is the nature of language; words are symbols that point to things and concepts. Shakespeare said “That which we call a rose by any other name would smell as sweet,”[2] but it was Mad Magazine who added, “yes, but would you pay the same price for a dozen stink weed?”[3]

We all use words as symbols in our daily lives. But sometimes, some of the symbolism is lost. In this case, it’s a matter of not knowing the nuances of ancient languages and cultures. We can be informed about these things, we can learn. We now know that we must be born again from above. We know that the words for wind and Spirit are the same in both Greek and Hebrew, and the Spirit moves us as the wind moves us. We also know that the lifting up of Jesus is done in our hearts and our hands and our voices, as well as on the cross.

In verse three, Jesus tells us about the person of God. Jesus tells us that we can only see the kingdom of heaven when we are born again from above. Only when we receive this second birth, a birth that comes from God, can we ever see the kingdom of God. Jesus tells us that the Spirit that blows us like the wind is in control of our lives. We can never control the wind; we can only be controlled by it. Finally, Jesus tells us that just as the serpent was lifted up, Jesus would be lifted up. And yes, Jesus is lifted up on the pole of Roman execution as he is lifted up in exaltation by his father and by us. Three little pieces of wordplay we receive from a very smart, very witty Messiah.

In this wordplay, John gives us a taste of what the trinity looks like. Here we get a look at how Jesus describes himself, and the rest of the Godhead to Nicodemus, a teacher who believed.

This is Trinity Sunday. It is the day that the church celebrates the triune God, God in three persons. To discern the Triune God, God who is three in one, we have to look beyond individual words of scripture. We can only discern the trinity through additional interpretation, a little more word play. So let me begin by saying we testify that there is one God, and God is presented in scripture in three different persons traditionally called the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit.

One of the controversies of the trinity is that people of other faiths see “God in three persons” and think we believe in and pray to three gods. This is not so. We recognize that God is present in three distinct persons, but are all from the same essence of God. God exists in separate persons in eternal relationship with one another. They are distinct, but inseparable. They are present in different means, but in only one way. One may send another, but this does not suggest subservience of one to another.

We also testify that each of these persons participate with the others in every realm of the creation. Some in the church have quit referring to the trinity with the gender specific names of the persons. Instead, formulae like “creator, redeemer, and sustainer” are used to refer to the modes in which God operates. This “God in three modes” does not accurately describe the scriptural witness of the triune God. All three persons of the trinity behave as creator, redeemer, and sustainer. These roles are not delegated to any one person of the trinity.

It’s said that Jesus doesn’t answer questions very well. And this is true for us, but this is how Rabbis talked to one another. This conversation with Nicodemus is an example. It’s confusing for us; it is probably confusing to other Rabbis too. Maybe this is the point, trying to seek and find deeper truth; the Rabbis play a theological game of “Stump the Band.” So here Jesus stumps the Pharisee Nicodemus with his words. Jesus shows Nicodemus the seed of the trinity so that he may understand and believe. And believe so that he may not perish, but have eternal life. Indeed, as our reading ends, God sent the son so that the world may be saved through him.

[1] Numbers 21:7-8
[2] Romeo and Juliet, Act II, Scene 2
[3] Unknown, I was very young when I read this

Sunday, May 18, 2008

The Fullness of God

This sermon was heard at the First Presbyterian Church in Berryville, Arkansas on Sunday May 18, 2008, Trinity Sunday.

Genesis 1:1-2:4a
Psalm 8
2Corinthians 13:11-13
Matthew 28:16-20

May the words of my mouth and the meditations of our hearts be acceptable to you, O Lord, our rock and our redeemer. Amen

Theodore Roosevelt was the 26th President of the United States. Since he died before any of us was born, all that we know about him comes from what we learned in American History or heard from our parents and grandparents. He was truly the late 19th–early 20th Century version of the American Renaissance man. In his public life, he was a statesman, politician, president and public figure. In his life in the American West, he was a sportsman, hunter, explorer and soldier. His letters to his children show him as a winsome, lovable, gentle father, husband and family man. If we didn’t know, we might think that these are three different people, but we know him as one particular person.

You see where I’m going with this on Trinity Sunday, don’t you. Roosevelt in his way was three in one. Each one of these portraits was true to who Roosevelt was. We know enough from each one of them to know something. But even when we put them all together, we still don't know everything there is to know about who he was.[1]

I’m having trouble getting a handle on Trinity Sunday, especially since our gospel reading, the Great Commission, is perhaps the most evangelistic reading in the Gospel. So on this Trinity Sunday, what do we say about the Trinity?

Let’s begin here; the word “Trinity” is not found in scripture. It’s a theological term. It’s a way people describe God based on the witness of scripture. One of my theological dictionaries calls the Trinity “The coexistence of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit in the unity of the Godhead. While not a biblical term, ‘trinity’ represents the crystallization of New Testament teaching.”[2] That’s as good as any place to start.

The trinitarian formula used most frequently in our worship, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, is found in scripture. It was in today’s readings from 2Corinthians and Matthew. In 2Corinthians it is a blessing, a benediction to the benefit of the recipient. As we prepare to leave the sanctuary, I use this same benediction. In Matthew, it is used to describe the one God in three Persons we worship as we welcome new members into the community in the waters of baptism.

Of course, this formula is not without its critics. As humanity has explored the diverse possibilities for trinitarian images, there is a temptation to try to bring the mystery of God under our control.[3]

Some say it is gender specific; too male, not enough female. Even though we confess that the First Person of the Trinity is a most pure spirit without body, parts, or passions;[4] people get touchy about the maleness or femaleness of God. The quantity of masculine words to identify God in scripture only adds to the controversy.

Others note that people whose fathers weren’t present or were abusive have difficulty seeing God as the figure of a good Father, father with a capital “F.” I can’t disagree with this, after all, earthly fathers are a sin-soaked people; just like everyone else. But unfortunately, our earthly perceptions of fathers infect our perception of God the Father who we confess is infinite in being and perfection.[5]

Another issue with the history and theology of the Trinity is that some considered Jesus the Christ and the Holy Spirit to be secondary deities, subordinate to the First Person of the Trinity. But the church affirms that Jesus and the Spirit are not some lackey or servant gods to a supposedly supreme God when in truth all three persons of God are equal to one another.

Additionally, some have renamed the persons of the Trinity based on what we think are their usual roles. The most common of these is “Creator, Redeemer, and Sustainer.” This isn’t good because it tries to cubby-hole the works of God into a specific person of God. This is not the nature of the Triune God. For example, our Genesis passage this morning speaks directly to the Spirit’s role in creation as the wind that swept across the face of the waters. Our Psalm sings of God the Great I AM as the one who protects and sustains us.

All three persons of God create, redeem, sustain, and so much more. We need to remember that naming the Triune God by roles hides the truth of the scriptural witness and the nature of the fullness of God.

Our human efforts to tame the names of God have helped humanity homogenize God into compartments based on our perceptions of what God does. It has helped us put God into a hierarchy that would make a business tycoon proud. It has helped us infect the glory of God by our individual perceptions. By speaking of the Three Persons of God in these ways, in a very human way, we limit God. But the Triune God is not contained by human frailty.

Two years ago, the General Assembly voted to accept a report on this issue,[6] a Presbyterian look at the Trinity. It included this great truth: “Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit are, together with God the Father, fully and eternally God. As the Nicene Creed affirms, Jesus Christ is ‘God from God, Light from Light, true God from true God,’ and the Holy Spirit is to be worshiped and glorified as ‘the Lord, the giver of life.’”[7]

All three persons of the Triune God are eternal and equal. As the Triune God, the three persons cannot be separated from one another yet they are distinct from one another.

Now, if you think this is beginning to sound more like three Gods than one God in three persons, I can’t blame you. Perhaps one of the most important things we can say about the Trinity is that the concept of “Trinity” is a model, a way of explaining the mystery of God.

The PC(USA) Trinity Report puts it this way, “The mystery of the Trinity is an open and radiant mystery. It is the mystery of the truth that God is holy, abundant, overflowing love both in relationship with us and in all eternity. We meet God’s threefold love in astonishing faithfulness of the Holy One of Israel, in the costly grace given to us in Jesus Christ our Savior, and in the new life in communion with God and others that has come to us in the gift of the Holy Spirit.”[8]

The best way I have found of describing how to imagine the Trinity comes from the Swiss theologian Karl Barth who said “in it we are speaking not of three divine I’s, but thrice of the one divine I.”[9] There is one divine presence who has been shown to us in three distinct persons, shown to us in scripture, and still being shown to us today by grace. God in three persons is diverse, and in one, the Triune God is united.

The question becomes “What do we do with this knowledge?

One of the places we can find the answer to this question is in our Prayer for Illumination:

God, whose fingers sculpt sun and moon
and curl the baby’s ear;
spirit, brooding over the chaos
before the naming of the day;
Savior, sending us to the earth’s ends
with water and words:
startle us with the grace, love, and communion
of your unity and diversity,
that we may live to the praise of your majestic name.[10]

Excepting the prayer’s creeping modalism, it gives us an important clue. There are two distinct motions to this prayer, remembering what we know about the one who creates us and showing how we are to respond to God in praise and to creation in love and service.

The love of the Triune God overflows from the relationship of the three persons. We were created to share in that love, that wonder, that joy. We can’t repay God for the love we are shown; so what we must do, all we can do, is love in return. Love God and love one another in word and in deed.

When we claim the overflowing love of the Triune God we are called to respond. “[The doctrine of the Trinity] must be put into practice in our everyday life. It has its roots in the proclamation of the gospel and in the church’s life in prayer.”[11]

And as our reading from Matthew teaches, we follow the command to make disciples; sharing this love by going into the world, baptizing in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching obedience to everything the Lord has commanded.

This is a daunting command, but with this command we are given the assurance that Jesus, the Son of God and the Son of Man, will be with us to the end of the age. Rely on this and rely on the overflowing love in the fullness of the Triune God Almighty, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

[1] Homiletics Online, attributed to Harry Emerson Fosdick with an editorial contribution, http://www.homileticsonline.com/subscriber/illustration_search.asp?item_topic_id=902, retrieved May 16, 2008.
[2] “Trinity,” Interpreter’s Dictionary of the Bible
[3] Office of Theology and Worship, PC(USA), “The Trinity: God’s Love Overflowing.” PC(USA): Louisville, KY, 2004,, lines 354-355
[4] Westminster Confession of Faith, Chapter II, Paragraph 1. In the PC(USA) Book of Confessions this is found at 6.011.
[5] Ibid.
[6] Note that I wrote “accepted” and not “approved.” Because of the controversial nature of this report the General Assembly of the PC(USA) did not approve this report but instead voted to accept it.
[7] Ibid, Office of Theology and Worship, lines 217-220.
[8] Ibid. lines 245-249.
[9] Barth, Karl, “Church Dogmatics.” Volume I.1.Edinburgh: T & & Clark, 1975, page 351.
[10] Reprinted from Revised Common Lectionary Prayers, Year A, Trinity Sunday, Prayer of Illumination, copyright 2002.
[11] Ibid, Office of Theology and Worship, lines, 483-484.

Sunday, June 03, 2007

Team Player

This sermon was delivered at the First Presbyterian Church in Berryville, Arkansas on Trinity Sunday, June 3, 2007.

Proverbs 8:1-4, 22-31
Psalm 8
Romans 5:1-5
John 16:12-15

May the words of my mouth and the meditations of our hearts be acceptable to you, O Lord, our rock and our redeemer. Amen.

For those of you who don’t like sports analogies, you will find this tedious, but it makes my point. The other day I was reading an article[1] that says the superstars of today would rather be famous than great. In this scathing indictment, the writer compared Michael Jordan, the greatest basketball player of the 1980’s and 90’s—and arguably of all time—with the greatest basketball player of today, LeBron James. The author’s contention is while Jordan was willing to carry his team on his back to become basketball champions; James is satisfied with his reputation and his paycheck, both of which are sizable. Jordan was a star not just by getting his points, but by making his teammates better where it is said James is just happy putting up numbers. The sports writer said that to take his game to the next level. LeBron has to make the tough choices, take the important shots, and put his team on his back. That’s the only way he will be able to lead his team into the Promised Land, the NBA finals. Many sports pundits said the best example of this was at the end of game two of the NBA Eastern Conference Finals. With seconds to go, LeBron could have sent the game into overtime if he had gone to the hoop. Instead, he kicked the ball out to the perimeter where a teammate missed the potential game winning shot. Some approved of LeBron passing the ball saying it was unselfish play. Others said that as the best player in the league, he needed to take the shot. As Gene Hackman once said, “Winners always want the ball when the game is on the line.”[2]

Of course, this can go to extremes, Keyshawn Johnson, an NFL wide receiver who wrote a memoir called “Just Give Me the Damn[3] Ball,” raised some eyebrows with his ability, and a few more with his attitude. It was often said that regardless of how talented he is as a receiver, all of the other things he brought to the field overshadowed his ability. Where Michael Jordan carried his team and his league on his broad shoulders, Keyshawn Johnson always seemed to carry his like baggage. Where Jordan was the consummate teammate, Keyshawn always had the attitude that what he could do was the only thing that could help the team. So, who would you want as a teammate?

Today the church celebrates Trinity Sunday. This is the day we give thanks and glory to God in three persons, the Blessed Trinity. But here’s an interesting fact, never in scripture is the word “trinity” used to describe the Holy Triumvirate. The Old Testament, the portion of scripture predating Jesus, certainly doesn’t mention the Trinity. The Gospels don’t talk about the three distinct yet inseparable persons of God. The Acts of the Apostles and the Epistles don’t make the leap from the individual persons of God to the Trinity either. Revelation features each of the three persons prominently, but never is the concept of the Trinity used or defined.

The concept of the Trinity comes from biblical interpretation and theology instead of coming directly from scripture. In a way the Trinity is revealed through scripture instead of in scripture. The word Trinity was coined by the great theologian Tertullian late in the second century. But Tertullian couldn’t refer to a book or scroll that looked like what we call a bible. The collection of scripture we call the bible wasn’t assembled and standardized until early in the fourth century. So here’s a dilemma, how do we as bible believing Christians celebrate something that isn’t in our bible, a bible that didn’t exist as we know it until a hundred years after the concept was first mentioned?

The answer is not only are we called to read and study scripture; we are also called to interpret scripture. And today’s readings are a great place to start.

When I was in school, the English teachers in my district quit teaching how to diagram sentences. I don’t know if mine was an isolated example or if schools have quit teaching diagramming all together. One of the goals of diagramming sentences is to organize clauses and phrases to help identify the grammatical elements of a sentence and how they relate to one another. If I have learned one thing about John’s gospel over the past couple of months it’s that being able to diagram sentences would have come in handy, very handy.

In our gospel reading this morning, Jesus gives us a picture of how the three persons of the Trinity interact with one another, and then how they interact with us. Jesus tells us that the Spirit of Truth comes to guide us into all truth. The Spirit does not speak on its own, but speaks what is heard and then declares to us what is to come. The Spirit does this to glorify Jesus, and as we recall from last week’s scripture reading,[4] what the Son does he does to glorify the Father. What belongs to Jesus, the Spirit will take and declare to us. Finally, all that the Father has belongs to Jesus. So all that one of the persons of the Trinity has—is shared with each of the others –and then is declared to us.

This belonging and giving is difficult for us to understand. But then our reading begins with Jesus saying that he has many things to tell us, things we cannot bear now. Jesus knows we will never be able to fully understand the eternal relationship between the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit on this side of Glory. So if we don’t understand, don’t be afraid, don’t mourn, don’t be anxious. Jesus says we can’t bear all of what he has to say, so he doesn’t expect us to know everything. Not understanding is fine; in fact, it’s the way of things.

But what we can’t know in our heads, through faith we can know in our very beings. Through faith we are justified. Through faith we have the peace of God through our Lord Jesus Christ. We can celebrate the Trinity, God who scripture unfolds as the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit because God calls the church, calls us to take the grace and the peace of Jesus Christ that the Spirit reveals to us into the world as ambassadors.

Team players. When involved in a team sport it is important to be a team player. As for LeBron James, he answered his critics by taking the last shot in the third game of the NBA Eastern Conference Finals. James took the last shot which finally won that game after making the shots that sent the game into overtime and then into double overtime. Since the end of the second game of the series he literally put his team on his back and carried them. The exception was last night when he did not lead his team in points, but he led his team every other statistical category making his teammates better. Through his dominating play and his unselfish efforts, LeBron James led his team past the Detroit Pistons last night and into the NBA finals.

As for Keyshawn Johnson, as a member of the Carolina Panthers and an analyst for ESPN television’s coverage of the NFL College Player Draft six weeks ago, he was excited to learn his team drafted a wide receiver from his alma mater. Keyshawn couldn’t wait to show him the ropes, until Carolina showed Keyshawn the door. Since getting cut from the team, Keyshawn has retired from playing and is now a full time football analyst for ESPN.

Being a team player means knowing your role, knowing your role is important, and knowing your role will change. Sometimes it will mean putting the team on your back and carrying them to victory. Other times it means doing everything you can to make teammates better. In their own way, the three persons of God are one team. The three persons of the Trinity exist in perfect relationship with one another. Their dance is eternal, the way it has been since before the beginning. And God in three persons invites us to join that dance. God invites us to be a team player, a player on God’s team. We are invited through the free gift of God’s grace. We receive this gift of grace through faith and by faith we are justified. Hope will never disappoint us because God’s love has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit. As the people of the Triune God, we are called to respond to this hope sharing the bounty of grace we have been given with the world. This way we will be great, instead of just famous.

[1] I am unable to find the source again, I wish I was able to so that I could cite the original author and so I could make sure I got the thought completely right.
[2] “The Replacements” Bel Air Entertainment, 2000
[3] I mumbled this word in the church.
[4] John 14:8-17, 25-27