Showing posts with label Matthew 22. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Matthew 22. Show all posts

Sunday, October 23, 2011

Divine Priorities

This sermon was heard at the First Presbyterian Church in Marshall, Texas on Sunday October 23, 2011, the 30th Sunday in Ordinary Time.

Podcast of "Divine Priorities" (MP3)

Deuteronomy 34:1-12
Psalm 90:1-6, 13-17
1 Thessalonians 2:1-8
Matthew 22:34-46

May the words of my mouth and the meditations of our heart be acceptable to you, O Lord, our rock and our redeemer.  Amen.

In 2003, the British Broadcasting Corporation created a project called “The Big Read” to find the most popular novels among British readers.[1] You may have seen a version of this on the internet or on facebook.[2] Currently, I’m reading #25 on the list, J.R.R. Tolkien’s “The Hobbit.”[3] Written in the mid 1930’s for his children, “The Hobbit” is the story of the adventures of Bilbo Baggins. In one of his many adventures, Bilbo finds the ring which becomes the center of “The Lord of the Rings.” “The Lord of the Rings” by the way sits in the top spot on the Big Read.[4]

Bilbo finds the ring in a goblin cave where he has been taken prisoner. Eluding the goblins by the ring’s power of invisibility, Bilbo finds a scary character named Gollum while trying to find his way out. They meet at cross purposes. Bilbo wants Gollum to help him escape while Gollum wants to eat Bilbo where he stands. They decide to settle the matter with a game of riddles.[5] The one who asks the stumping riddle gets what he wants.

Gollum goes first asking:

What has roots as nobody sees,
Is taller than the trees,
Up and up it goes,
And yet never grows?

Bilbo gets that one quickly, a mountain. After several rounds of riddles Bilbo asks:

A box without hinges, key, or lid,
Yet golden treasure inside is hid.

Gollum gets that one, an egg. Bilbo finally catches Gollum asking “What have I got in my pocket?” Not a proper riddle, Bilbo gives Gollum three guesses, all of which are unsuccessful. This displeases Gollum of course, since he loses his meal at the expense of what is not a proper riddle he feels inclined to neither show Bilbo out of the caves nor take him from the lunch menu. As I’m sure you know by now, if for no other reason than he appears in “The Lord of the Rings,” Bilbo escapes and with him the ring.

Riddles have long been a test of wits, knowledge, reason, and wisdom. The Sadducees and Pharisees tried and failed to trip up Jesus with little tests, tests shaped like the riddles Bilbo and Gollum exchanged with one another.

The Pharisees riddled Jesus with questions about taxes. Jesus tells them to render unto Caesar what is Caesar’s and render unto God what is God’s.[6] Jesus neither betrays the government nor the faith, a show of great wisdom.

Then the Sadducees asked Jesus a question about levirate marriage (which came straight out of Deuteronomy 25) and the resurrection (which didn’t) in an effort to trip him up on his knowledge of the law. Jesus tells them their riddle is ridiculous because they know neither the scriptures nor the power of God.[7] In addition, the Sadducees didn’t believe in the resurrection in the first place, so their question is a fool’s errand, an errand Jesus doesn’t go on.

So the Pharisees take another shot, this is what we hear today in our gospel reading. They ask, “Teacher, which is the greatest commandment in the Law?” Like I said a couple of weeks ago, we don’t know if the question is being asked as a trap or by a sincere follower of the faith seeking wisdom. Since I have called this a riddle you can see that I lean toward the trap, but in truth we don’t know.

What we do know is that he gives them more answer than they expected. “Jesus replied: “‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind.’” This is the first and greatest commandment. And the second is like it: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’ All the Law and the Prophets hang on these two commandments.”

As I said, this is more than the legal expert expected. The lawyer expected to hear what is known by Israelites since the days of Deuteronomy as “Shema.” The confession of Deuteronomy 6:4 is a prayer that goes, “Shema Israel, Adonai Eluhinu, Adonai echad.” In English we say, “Hear O Israel, the Lord is your God, the Lord is one.” What immediately follows in 6:5 is what Jesus says to the Pharisees, “You shall love the LORD your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your strength.”

What a lovely prayer! This is the sort of prayer we need in our lives everyday. “The Lord is our God, the Lord is one. We shall love the Lord our God with all our heart, and with all our soul, and with all our might.” This is as Jesus tells the Pharisees “the first and greatest commandment.”

Now for the bonus, Jesus tells the Pharisees “And a second is like it: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’” This is Jesus quoting Leviticus 19:18. This is a scathing indictment against his inquisitors. We talk of the Golden Rule, “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” While not the intention, the Golden Rule can be met with benign indifference. “I’ll ignore you if you’ll ignore me.” Well, Jesus’ answer tells us differently, we are to love one another, never treating one another indifferently.

Something else that comes up missing in our English reading is that when Jesus says the second is like the first he is saying that they are equally important. Israel knew the Shema, and they knew how they were to love the Lord their God. But Jesus indicts them saying they have not fulfilled the requirements of the greatest commandment. They may know the first part, but they lack in the second.

These confrontations between Jesus and the temple leaders are called controversy stories. The controversy stories are the words of God that turned the world on its ear. These are the words where the Lord challenged the conventional wisdom of the temple and of the day and made the world take notice that God was doing something new in the person of Jesus the Christ, by the power of the Holy Spirit. It is no wonder that they are called controversies.

There is controversy in the Presbyterian Church USA too; the denomination I mean. One of these bru-ha-ha’s is whether we are a denomination that shares the word of God with the world making new disciples or whether we are a denomination that seeks to do God’s justice in the world. If you want to speak in the jargon of our denomination’s talking heads, they will say it’s the difference between being a missional church and being a social justice church. It is a serious question and one that has occupied the church for years and may for decades more. The people who ask these questions are quite serious about these questions and more serious seeking their answers.

It is the church seeking divine priorities.

Well, here’s my take based on what we have just read. There is no difference between loving God and doing God’s good works. There is no difference between loving the Lord our God and loving our neighbor as ourselves. One is as important as the other. To do one and not the other fails to carry the Word and work of God into the world. They must be done together.

Jesus has said that one is as important as the other. When one or the other is missing something very important is missing. The Epistle of James says faith without works is dead. I follow that saying good works without faith is rudderless. If we do as God desires without faith, it is by sheer luck. Neither is dependable. Neither helps fulfill the Great Ends of the Church.

According to the commentary, “Leviticus 19,” the source of the call to love our neighbors, “offers an extensive vision of a world marked by just human relations and practical care. Jesus has demonstrated this vision in his ministry and has criticized the leaders for failing to do so.”[8]

Jesus finishes saying “On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets.” Jesus tells them that not only these two sayings together is the greatest commandment, he tells them that their entire faith is rooted here. Loving God and your neighbor; the essence of the written Word and the call of the Living Word, is the greatest commandment of all.

Riddles, riddles, riddles. To end our reading, Jesus asks his own riddle. He begins like a good baseball pitcher setting up the pitch. He asks, “What do you think about the Messiah? Whose son is he?” They said to him, “The son of David.” This is right, so far so good, but this is the set up, not the pitch.

Jesus reminds them David was speaking, singing filled with the Holy Spirit and the temple leaders nod. He asks them, “How is it then that David calls [the Messiah] ‘Lord’? For he says,

‘The Lord said to my Lord:
            “Sit at my right hand
until I put your enemies
under your feet.”’

Jesus focuses the question. Based on this Psalm, Jesus asks, “If then David calls [the Messiah] Lord, how can he be his son?”

Now, this isn’t a difficult question for Christians. With two-thousand years of scripture and interpretation and worship and theology and education; we say with great confidence that Jesus of Nazareth, son of Joseph, son of David, son of Judah is the long awaited Messiah. Jesus is the Christ.

Jesus challenges the Pharisees to say what we know, that Jesus is Lord. This son of David is the Son of God and the Son of Man. Lo, they cannot. It may be hidden from them, or perhaps it is revealed but denied. Maybe some want to sing Jesus is the Messiah while others would rather keep things as they were. It wasn’t perfect, but their situation in Roman controlled Palestine could be much, much worse. Regardless, Matthew’s gospel shows the result of this riddle. “No one could say a word in reply, and from that day on no one dared to ask him any more questions.”

Riddles are a test of wits, knowledge, reason, and wisdom. Guided by a wisdom that surpasses all understanding, Jesus wins this riddle game. The Light of the World answers the riddles in the dark. The Pharisees don’t have the imagination or the gumption or the wherewithal to follow Christ. We are called by God to use our imagination, our gumption, our wherewithal as well as our obedience to follow Christ in the power of the Spirit.

Jesus teaches us that we must love the Lord our God and our neighbor as ourselves. He teaches that loving God we are called to share the Word of God, the word written, living, and proclaimed, with all the world. He also teaches us this love is for the benefit of the community and the benefit of the kingdom.

We are called to proclaim that Jesus is the Son who sits at the right hand of the Lord. We are to proclaim that he is the Son of David from the line of Judah. He is the long awaited Messiah, he is the Christ.

We don’t have to wait. Our call is to make sure that nobody else has to wait for the Messiah either. We are to take Christ into the world in Word and deed. One without the other is not enough, we must do both. It is our choice, it is our call. We must decide not to follow one of these divine priorities; we are to follow the one divine priority.

As I said, I am reading “The Hobbit.” I’m about half-way though right now, but there are some things I know. For one, I now know how Bilbo came across the ring that plays such a central role in “The Lord of the Rings.” I also know that whatever adventures befall Bilbo he will survive. I know this simply because I know he has to get back to the Shire and his Hobbit hole one way or another.

As for what I know about the faith, I don’t know how the Triune God will use these words this morning, but I do know this: By the power of the Holy Spirit, they will be useful. I don’t know how Bilbo will make it home, but I know he does. I don’t know how God’s work will be done, but I know it will be. This I am sure.

To find out about Bilbo I have to read the book, one page at a time. To find out what God has in store for me, in store for us, I have to follow, one day, one moment at a time. In the book of life, may all glory be to the Lord our God. The Lord is our God, the Lord is one.

[1] BBC.com, “The Big Read.” http://www.bbc.co.uk/arts/bigread/top100.shtml, retrieved October 22, 2011.
[2] On a side note, the facebook version does not match the true 2003 BBC list. The facebook list includes some things that are collections or groups of books and do not meet the “book” criteria. The BBC list considered only individual titles. The facebook version includes “The Chronicles of Narnia” which is a collection of seven titles and not a single book; hence, it did not make the true BBC list. "The Works of Shakespeare" was also on the list, but it is not a novel but a collection of plays and poetry. Follow the link above to see the original list. I don’t know how this rates, but I’ve read 15 out of the top 100 and six out of the top ten.
[3] Purchased at Sow’s Ear Antiques and Books in Berryville, Arkansas. Thanks Dan. Support local businesses!
[4] While published as a trilogy, LOTR was conceived and meant to be published as a single book. Narnia was always a seven volume series of individual books.
[5] From Tolkien, J.R.R., “The Hobbit.” Chapter 5 “Riddles in the Dark.” New York: Ballantine Books, 1937, 1938, 1966, 27th Ballantine Printing, 1989.
[6] Matthew 22:15-22
[7] Matthew 22:23-33
[8] New Interpreter’s Study Bible note for Matthew 22:39

Sunday, October 09, 2011

Always Being Reformed

This sermon was heard at the First Presbyterian Church in Marshall, Texas on Sunday October 10, 2011, the 28th Sunday in Ordinary Time.

Podcast of "Always Being Reformed" (MP3)

Podcast Powered By Podbean

Exodus 32:1-14
Psalm 106:1-6, 19-23
Philippians 4:1-9
Matthew 22:1-14

May the words of my mouth and the meditations of our hearts be acceptable to you, O Lord, our rock and our redeemer. Amen

One of the joys of cable and satellite TV is that there are hundreds and hundreds of channels; and once someone finds a program that works it is copied and spun off until there is a channel devoted to it. Sports channels began that way, so did the Fox Reality Channel until it went off the air. I’m waiting for “The Wedding Channel.” Somewhere, with all of the shows devoted to one bit of the wedding industry or the other, there’s going to be one place where “Bridezillas” everywhere can hook up with the “Cake Boss” and then “Say Yes to the Dress.”[1]

It is the nature of the parable to have several different kinds of truth in its words, this parable about a wedding banquet is no exception. There is historical and cultural truth. Since we are not fully familiar with those times, we may not catch some of those references. There is literary truth, because the parable as a form of literature contains truth in that context. There is also the truth of interpretation since there is nearly 2,000 years of analysis behind Matthew’s gospel.

So, let’s begin with the setting of our parable, the king who gave a wedding banquet for his son. One of the historical things we need to know is that before a wedding celebration, days or weeks in advance, the guests would have received invitations delivered by the king’s slaves. This announcement would not have the precise time or day of the wedding feast though. Another bit of history we need to know is that at this time weddings were not the timed to the minute thing they are today. It would take some time for the king’s slaves to prepare the great banquet.

Our parable doesn’t say how many oxen and fatted calves were slaughtered and prepared, but as it was a king who gave our parable’s banquet, we can imagine the number was substantial. The language tells us it was absolutely plural, so the preparations took quite a while. The banquet master would get in touch with the priest to butcher the animals. Then they would need to be cooked. How long does it take to cook not an ox but oxen? Just consider how long it takes to smoke a brisket an go up from there.

He would have needed the people who provided bread, spices, and other foods. And don’t forget the wine merchant. Since so many were involved in its preparation, the kingdom and all who were invited would know the feast was coming, just not exactly when.

Since preparing a wedding banquet was a long and inexact process, there was a two-step invitation procedure. The first invitation was sent so that the guests would know something was coming. The first invitation also made it so they would not be surprised when the slaves came with the “day of event” invitation.[2]

Another important historical element to this piece is that when the people say, “we’re busy” to the king’s servants; it means more than “we’re busy.” To reject the king’s invitation, or more properly the king’s command, is an act of rebellion. To do it en masse is a sign of conspiracy.[3] Historically, no king would stand for this.

Parables are great, but these historical and cultural nuances that the chief priests, elders, and Pharisees would have known are lost on us until we learn them. There are elements of truth in the history and culture of this story, but there is truth beyond history and culture.

Another part of the truth comes from the literary qualities of the parable. One of the key concepts of the parable is that it is not a true story. Even though as we have just heard, there is historical truth mixed in, this story does not reflect an actual event.

So in our story, after the slaves return to the king mistreated and worse, the king wages war on those who reject him and his invitation. This part of the story should be a red flag that this is not a true story. I ask what king would delay his son’s wedding and let his supper get cold to go and wage war on a city, his city? This is wonderfully epic, filled with dramatic exaggeration, and highly unlikely.

As a nation, our recent experience with “shock and awe” warfare shows there is no way to wage war and be home for dinner in any age. So in the realm of factual events, the battle described in this story would not have happened. But in the parable we are given a clear lesson, we see that those who betrayed the king got what they deserved.

As literature, this parable brings us a broad epic sense of scope which the story misses without its literary elements. It’s not that all pieces of the parable add up, but as a story, there is truth within the exaggeration.

As for truth found in interpretation, there is much. This is the third of three parables Jesus spoke to the Pharisees, chief priests, and elders in the temple. Scholars say the first parable, the one of the two sons, focuses on John the Baptist and the people’s response to his ministry. The second, the parable of the vineyard, uses allegory to interpret Jerusalem’s fall as punishment for the leaders’ unfaithfulness. This third parable is a final warning to the church of Jesus Christ to remain faithful and not follow the footsteps of the Pharisees, chief priests, and elders.[4]

The history of interpretation gives us a chronological progression of stories warning the Pharisees, chief priests and elders who rejected John; then rejected the prophets and then the Son; and a final warning that the church might never reject Jesus and the vocation he has lain upon it.

Often, we speak of faith in terms of putting on new clothes. We talk of the church as being the bride of Christ. So a part of the history of interpretation leads us to be called to put on Christ as we join together with him as his bride.

The truth found in the history of interpretation is that while all are called, those who do not respond to this call are dealt with harshly. I am not saying that we are saved by works because we are saved by grace through faith. I am saying that there are dire consequences if we accept the Lord’s invitation and all we do is show up expecting to be fed.[5] This judgment was true in the days of the prophets, in the days of Jesus, and it is true for us today.

Ecclesia reformata, semper reformanda; the church reformed and always reforming. This has been the call of the reformed churches since the days of Luther, Calvin, Knox and dozens of others. These words are being shared still in Sunday Schools, pulpits, and in seminaries. These words are important to what we understand as our specific place in the Body of Christ, the universal Church.

There is another way to translate this statement which I prefer. “The church having been reformed is always being reformed.” It’s longer and not nearly as catchy, but it’s important for us. This translation maintains the Latin verb forms[6] which focus on God’s work on the church. The church is not an active participant in the kingdom, it’s passive. This is important, from a grammatical point of view, it’s passive not active.

This means that we can do nothing on our own, it is only by God in Christ, it is only by our salvation. It is only by our constant sanctification that we can make any difference at all. The church exists only to do God’s work shaped by God alone. The church does work, but only under the authority of Christ by the power of the Holy Spirit.

The chief priests, elders, and Pharisees seemed to have forgotten this. They thought they were the king, the mice and the cheese[7] and they thought they had the world by the tail. They knew their positions were precarious, the Holy Land was under Roman rule, but they had the system figured out… as long as nothing changed.

Jesus was there to tell them that times were changing. Using three parables of judgment, Jesus shows us, history teaches Jesus did not show them, Jesus shows us that there is peace and there is grace, but it is not cheap. God paid a great price, suffering death on the cross to give us what we could never earn.

So like the guests who came to the banquet, we are called to be transformed, reformed, and dressed in our own wedding robe. If we are not transformed by God’s invitation truly we are in no better shape than those who rejected Jesus 2,000 years ago.

Today Marla and Baby Elizabeth will put on that robe. Symbolically they will receive the sign of the beginning of Christian transformation in the waters of baptism. They have been called and they have chosen to answer. God honors the sacraments he institutes.

Our reading ends as Jesus says that many are called but few are chosen. While this sounds like a threat, it is actually a promise. It sounds like a warning, but it is a goal. It is up to us to live into our baptism. It is up to us to remember these promises, the ones we made when we were baptized. It is up to us to remember these promises when we were baptized as babes and someone made them for us. It is up to us to remember the promises we have made as elders, sponsors, and members of this part of the Body of Christ. This is how we begin to remember our baptism.

Now it’s up to us, do we remember and live into the promises of God or do we fade into the antiquity of the chief priests, elders, and Pharisees? Friends, let us go to the banquet and put on the wedding coat of the Lord. Let us remember the waters of our baptism. Let us approach God in joy and peace. Let us be reformed, and continue always being reformed.

[1] Actually, it has been done, a couple of times; at least once as a TV channel and more recently as in internet portal. So the idea’s out there, all it needs is a little more traction and then it’s off to the races.
[2] The New Interpreter’s Bible. Vol. VIII. Leander Keck, General Editor. Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1995, page 417.
[3] Ibid.
[4] Ibid. pages 412-419
[5] Ibid. page 419
[6] “Reformata” is the Perfect Passive form of the verb. This denotes action performed with future implications. “Reformanda” is the Passive Present form which means action is taking place on it, not by it.
[7] Title of an old children’s book.

Sunday, November 02, 2008

Exceedingly Ordinary

This sermon was heard at the First Presbyterian Chruch in Berryville, Arkansas on Sunday November 2, 2008, the 31st Sunday in Ordinary Time.

Joshua 3:7-17
Psalm 107:1-7, 33-37
1 Thessalonians 2:1-8
Matthew 22:34-46

May the words of my mouth and the meditations of our hearts be acceptable to you, O Lord, our rock and redeemer. Amen

The pressure to be exceptional is a cause of many illnesses. When we put too much pressure on ourselves, we cause the stress in our lives to become amplified far beyond what is healthy. We make a swift move from the stress that we need in life to distress which can kill us.

What’s more, our attempts to be exceptional can actually lead to unhappiness. Lyndon Duke,[1] who studies suicide, has found that when people try to be extraordinary, nearly everyone fails. They end up feeling like losers for not being good enough, special enough, rich enough or happy enough. The result of trying to be exceptional is very often a life of unhappiness.

There has to be a better way. And fortunately there is; one that involves humility. Mr. Duke’s own story shows us the way.

Duke was moping around feeling unhappy one day, when all of a sudden he began to hear a neighbor singing while he was mowing his lawn. In a moment of clarity, he realized what was missing from his life: the simple pleasures of an average day. He realized that he needed to stop trying to exalt himself; simply accepting the ordinary life that he and his family had been given.

The very next weekend, he went to visit his son, who was struggling to excel in his first semester at college. Duke spoke very clearly to him, saying, “I expect you to be a straight C student, young man. I want you to complete your unremarkable academic career, meet an ordinary young woman, and, if you choose, get married and live a completely average life!”

His son, of course, thought he had flipped. But Duke was advising him to enjoy the height of humility; to be an average student, and enjoy an ordinary life.

The result of this advice was quite surprising. No longer feeling any pressure to be exceptional, Duke’s son did an average amount of studying for his final exams. His grades were outstanding: straight A’s.

He then called his dad and apologized.

This story points to the paradox of an average-life philosophy: If you focus on living an ordinary life, the cumulative effect of many average days becomes extraordinary. Little steps add up. Serving others produces great results. Those who humble themselves will be exalted, says Jesus. An extraordinary life usually begins with being exceedingly ordinary.

Notice this doesn’t say that we should be doormats for others. Jesus isn’t suggesting that we subject ourselves to abuse. No, he is saying that we should turn away from arrogance, and turn toward humility. Be a student he says; be a disciple of the Messiah, a humble servant. It’s through a life of ordinary service that we accomplish extraordinary things.

True story: Paul Farmer[2] grew up in a trailer park in Florida, went to Duke and Harvard Medical School, and earned an M.D. and a Ph.D. He could’ve decided to practice medicine in an elite and lucrative practice anywhere in the country, but in his mid-30s he was working in Boston for a third of the year, living in a church rectory in a slum, and the rest of the year he was working without pay in Haiti, providing medical care to peasants who had lost their land to a hydroelectric dam. In 1987, he helped to create a nonprofit organization called “Partners in Health,” with both medical and moral missions. By 2003, this group was treating 1,000 patients per day in the Haitian countryside, free of charge, and was also working to cure drug-resistant tuberculosis among prisoners in Siberia and in the slums of Peru.

The height of humility is a life of service that has created a world of good. And people have noticed this quiet work. Although not one to exalt himself, Dr. Farmer has received a “genius grant” from the MacArthur Foundation, and a $1.5 million Conrad N. Hilton Humanitarian Prize.

Of course, not all of us have degrees from Harvard and the resources of a genius grant. Regardless of who we are and how we make our livings, we can choose to live a truly humble life that is anything but average. Wherever we are on the socioeconomic spectrum, the words of Jesus ring true: “All who exalt themselves will be humbled, and all who humble themselves will be exalted.”

This certainly sounds simple enough. Of course, sounds like this are deceptive. The phrase “easier said than done” comes to mind. There is a lot of pressure, some of it comes from family, colleagues, peers, and neighbors; and the rest is the pressure we put on ourselves. It’s a deceptive thing to say that “we’re just trying to be the best people we can be; it’s not like we’re trying to be God.” And that’s the big trap; the one we may not even know has a hold of us.

We testify that Jesus is now and has always been fully human and fully divine. We testify that he is without sin; until he takes our sin upon himself at Calvary that is. Then he feels the all too human pain of rejection crying, “Father, Father, why have you forsaken me?”[3] Even knowing all of this, this is going to sound a little strange: Not only is Jesus more divine than we will ever be, he is also more human than we will ever be.

One more time, not only is Jesus more divine than we will ever be, he is more human than we will ever be.

Because of sin, we can never be fully human. There is eternally a separation between the humanity we experience and the experience of humanity our Lord created for us. This perfect humanity is the life Jesus lived. This isn’t another invitation for us to make ourselves into doormats. No body can be all things to all people; it isn’t in our make up. It isn’t an invitation to beat ourselves up because we aren’t perfect either. After all, we can’t be perfect. This is instead the time to know that we all have limitations, not one of us does not.

Here’s the invitation, we are to be all that we can be in Christ, because in Him we can do all things. It is when we try to be extraordinary in ourselves that we will be humbled. The call Jesus lays upon our lives is to live where ordinary faithfulness leads to extraordinary things.

To live a humble life, it’s important to avoid the three mistakes that the scribes and the Pharisees make.[4] First, they do not practice what they teach. They are hypocrites, saying one thing and doing another. If we are to be humble servants of Christ and have a positive impact on the world, we need to make sure that our deeds are in line with our words. This is true because in this world people are always going to be watching to see if we are people of integrity, showing consistency between our words and our actions.

Second, the scribes and Pharisees lay burdens on the shoulders of others, burdens they are unwilling to bear themselves. These religious leaders apply the ancient purity laws of the Israelites to the people as a whole. Jesus clearly considers this an unfair burden. When people are in need, it is critical for us to go beyond giving advice; we also need to lend a hand.

Finally, they do all their deeds to be seen by others; being more interested in appearances than in having a relationship with God. Seats in the synagogue, fringes on prayer shawls and broad phylacteries, or in my case a robe and stole, can all play a role in good and faithful worship, but they lose their value when they are designed to exalt the person who is doing the praying.

Earlier in Matthew, Jesus condemns those who “love to stand and pray in the synagogues and at the street corners, so that they may be seen by others.” Instead, he recommends to his followers, “Whenever you pray, go into your room and shut the door and pray to your Father who is in secret; and your Father who sees in secret will reward you.”[5] Worship is about connecting with God, not impressing other people.

Avoiding these traps helps us to live a humble life, one in which the exceedingly ordinary becomes truly extraordinary. Practice what you teach. Offer a helping hand. Focus on God. These three tips are deceptively simple but deeply significant. They lie at the heart of a Christian life which makes a positive difference in the world.

In the end, we don’t get anywhere by exalting ourselves. The only real lift comes from exploring our humanity and the heights of humility. Instead of following the example set by the religious teachers, Jesus urges the crowds and disciples to understand that the kingdom is marked by humility. Those who would enter cannot rely on their own righteousness or piety.

Those who follow Jesus must answer to one Father, and not revel in any honor due on earth. Those who follow the Son must recognize only one Master, the Christ. It is not possible to be both self-serving and to practice God’s commandments. Those who follow the Lord must rely on the power of the Holy Spirit, and not on personal authority or status. This kingdom, as Matthew reminds his readers again and again, is one of reversal: “All who exalt themselves will be humbled, and all who humble themselves will be exalted.”[6]

[1] HomileticsOnline.com, http://www.homileticsonline.com/subscriber/btl_display.asp?installment_id=93040416, retrieved October 20, 2008.
[2] Ibid.
[3] Matthew 27:45
[4] HomileticsOnline.com, Ibid.
[5] Matthew 6:5-6.
[6] HomileticsOnline.com, Ibid.

Sunday, October 19, 2008

A Provocative Question or, So...What Is the Proper Tithe on $700 Billion?

This sermon was heard at the First Presbyterian Church in Berryville, Arkansas on Sunday October 19, 2008, the 29th Sunday of Ordinary Time.

Exodus 33:12-23
Psalm 99
1 Thessalonians 1:1-10
Matthew 22:15-22

May the words of my mouth and the meditations of our hearts be acceptable to you, O Lord, our rock and our redeemer. Amen

There is an old saying that religion and politics are two things best not discussed in public. In for a penny, in for a pound I say. We talk about religion all the time. In truth, I hope we talk more about faith than religion, but we do talk about religion. So today as we discuss rendering unto Caesar what belongs to Caesar, there is no way we can avoid talking about politics.

This is the time in the service of the worship of God when we read and interpret scripture. Reading and interpreting campaign speeches and debate transcripts will not bring glory to God, at least not in this setting. On the campaign trail there is talk of who is trustworthy with taxes and spending, and who is not. There is talk of who will bring change and who will be the hero of the same-old-same-old. There is talk of who is at fault and who is not. But I think with that one there is more than enough blame for everyone. All in all, it’s completely unnecessary for me to tell you how politically charged this last year has been, and these next two weeks will be.

And I don’t have to tell you that one of the elephants in the poling place will be the national economy, and this is where we return to our reading from Matthew.

The Pharisees and the Herodians meet Jesus in the temple and begin trying to corner him with flattery, “Teacher, we know that you are sincere, and teach the way of God in accordance with truth, and show deference to no one; for you do not regard people with partiality.” In any con game, and this is a con game, this is called “setting the mark.” The Pharisees and the Herodians are setting Jesus up for the kill, literally.

Tripping their snare they ask, “Tell us, then, what you think. Is it lawful to pay taxes to the emperor, or not?”

Jesus knew what they were doing. He knew their malice and their hypocrisy. He even asked why they were testing him. They thought there was no answer that would not trap him and get him into trouble with someone, and the Pharisees and the Herodians wanted Jesus trapped.

Our Lord is fully human and fully divine. I imagine in a fully human response to this challenge, Jesus was not impressed with their snare. Can’t you just see him sigh and oh so slightly shake his head?

Jesus asks for the coin to pay the tax and someone gives him a denarius. He asks, “Whose head is this, and whose title?” On the denarius is the image of the emperor and his full title, “Tiberius Caesar, Son of the Divine Augustus Pontifex Maximus.”[1] What belongs to the Emperor is to be given to the Emperor… and what belongs to God is to be given to God. The trap is disarmed. The Pharisees and Herodians, knowing they have been bested, went away in amazement.

Folks often quote scripture saying, “Render unto Caesar what belongs to Caesar.” Scripture affirms the value and need for the political state. The Reformed Confessions, one of the tools used by Presbyterians to interpret scripture, also affirm the value and need for the political state. In the 1930’s Swiss theologian Karl Bart wrote, “The State has by divine appointment the task of providing for justice and peace.”[2] I would only assume that the state would also have the power to assess taxes to provide justice and peace by this divine appointment.

Let us all beware, those of us with political power and those of us without. This paragraph goes on to warn “[This divine appointment] calls to mind the Kingdom of God, God's commandment and righteousness, and thereby the responsibility both of rulers and of the ruled.”[3] So beware, rulers will be judged as the one responsible for the wellbeing of the people. And let everyone else beware too, those who are ruled will be judged as those responsible for the wellbeing of the government.

If you have ever attended any worship service in any October or November, you have heard a message about what it means to render unto God what is God’s. But that is not today’s message. Today I want us to consider this question: Since God ordains and installs governments, what is the state obligated to return to God? How should it be returned? And what are the obligations of those who rule and those who are being ruled? What are the rich and the powerful and the poor and the powerless to do?

Bestselling author Thomas Cahill offers some thought on this question. “For those at the bottom their only ‘obligation’ (if that is not too strong a word) is to trust in God’s mercy. But the obligation of those on top is to exhibit God’s mercy toward those who have nothing.”[4]

Using the example of our Lord as a model, Cahill writes, “Jesus keeps two audiences clearly in view; the poor and the miserable; and those who, because they are neither poor nor miserable, have a religious obligation to stand in solidarity with those at the bottom of the heap.”[5] These are the obligations of the people and of the political state; those who rule and those who are ruled. How this is to be done is another matter entirely.

Last week I put a provocative question on our outdoor sign, “So…What’s the proper tithe on $700 billion?” As you know, the inspiration for this question comes from the “Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008,”[6] the $700 billion financial market bailout.

According to the act, the Secretary of Treasury is directed to acquire mortgages, mortgage backed securities, and other assets secured by residential real estate. It also authorizes the Secretary to use loan guarantees and credit enhancements to facilitate loan modifications to prevent avoidable foreclosures.”[7] Under this act, the secretary also “prescribes requirements for purchase and sale of assets using market mechanisms in a manner that will minimize any potential long-term negative impact on the taxpayer.”[8]

Allow me to paraphrase my understanding of this bill: Congress has authorized the Secretary of Treasury to purchase up to $700 billion of bad mortgages, bad mortgage backed securities, and other assets secured by residential real estate. And that number can go up. I have heard some pundits say the final cost of the bailout could end up between $1 and $5 trillion.

So how did our economic system get here? According to Nobel Prize winning economist Joseph Stiglitz, [9]

“The troubles we now face were caused largely by the combination of deregulation and low interest rates… Low interest rates and easy access to funds encouraged reckless lending, the infamous interest-only, no-down-payment, no-documentation subprime mortgages. It was clear that if the bubble got deflated even a little, many mortgages would end up under water—with the price less than the value of the mortgage. That has happened—12 million so far, and more every hour. Not only are the poor losing their homes, but they are also losing their life savings.”

This is the technical cause with its oh so real effects. But it does not help us grasp the culture that created this answer. In an article answering questions about the bailout, Time.com asked whether the legislation as it stands allows Wall Street executives to keep their bonuses or not.[10] Quoting:

“The Bush Administration says it needs [to allow executive bonuses] to encourage executives to get their cooperation, and that clamping down on their pay would only hurt their willingness to get on board.

What would the Sage of Omaha, Warren Buffett say about this deal? He got more concessions from a $5 billion stake in Bear Sterns than the government got with $700 billion.[11] More importantly, what would Jesus say about this deal? How do executive bonuses measure up to the obligation of those on top to exhibit God’s mercy toward those who have nothing?

Paraphrasing Galatians, Thomas Cahill writes, “Jesus told the Galatians not to go ‘snapping at one another and tearing one another to pieces’ (which some of them must have been doing). Even though ‘you were called to be free, do not use your freedom as an opportunity for self-indulgence, but be servants to one another in love, since the whole Law [of Moses] is summed up in a single commandment: Love your neighbor as yourself.’”[12]

Are these troubled financial institutions exhibiting God’s mercy? Do these leaders love their neighbors as they love themselves? No, this is the powerful and probably rich taking care of the suddenly not quite as rich who are suddenly not quite as powerful either. They have used their freedom for self-indulgence, not for the glory of God.

How does the state respond? It is the state’s vocation by divine appointment to provide for justice and peace. In its dealings with this crisis, the state appears more concerned with profit and loss for big companies than with justice and peace for the poor. Remembering the ancient story of the Maccabees, Cahill could have been talking about this plan when he writes how the temple leaders “had betrayed God and built ‘with blood a city of vanity,’ a city that robbed the poor to fatten the rich.”[13]

Nobel Economist Stiglitz says one of several things that must to happen to stem this economic tide is a forced conversion of this debt to equity. If this is done, the amount of government assistance that will be required will be much reduced.[14] The way this is being handled in the congressional bailout is by the government buying old bad securities pumping new dollars into the banks that made these loans. Then when these loans are worth something again, they will be resold to the banks.

This would increase assets and reduce bad debts for the mortgage lenders that made some very poor decisions in the first place. It would ultimately reward the very people who wrote all of these bad loans. I have another idea about how to reach this same goal.

I ask, at least from an accounting stand point, if it would not be as beneficial to use this money to purchase these bad debts and create equity not for banks, but for individuals. What if these funds paid down actual mortgages instead of paying mortgage backed securities? What if the equity that was gained was for individuals, for people, for citizens, and not for corporations? What if we used these funds to stabilize communities instead of stabilizing companies?

What if these funds not only put money in the banks, but put equity in the hands of individuals, particularly the poor? It would seem to meet Stiglitz’ plan, what it would not do is save those who tried to make money selling and reselling the paper these mortgages were written on.

It seems unrealistic. Forgiving individual debt would be tough. Purchasing mortgages and forgiving debt sounds outrageous. Some would say that it would be impossible, it can’t be done. That’s the point. This is the tithe God requires. The tithe God requires is not simply financial, it has very little to do with dollars, particularly in this circumstance. It has to do with changing our attitudes to invest in communities instead of companies. It has to do with people not things. It has to do with building and rebuilding roads, bridges, and infrastructure, not with paying the almighty dividend.

Cahill says, “[Jesus] was, in the mind of his followers and in his own view, ‘a prophet mighty in deed and word before God and all the people,’ the last of the prophets, the direct inheritor of the mantle of Amos, Isaiah, Jeremiah, Micah, and the whole long train of terrible figures who demanded the impossible—all of whom were shown to have been, in hindsight, far more realistic than their supposedly saner, more balanced contemporaries.”[15]

As I speak this morning, the polls for the American general election open in sixteen days, and in Arkansas early voting opens tomorrow. So let me say now I am not going to tell you how to vote in the coming election. There are many reasons why. For me, the most important reason is that telling you how to vote is the wrong thing to do as your pastor. Telling you how to vote is not a good pastoral move.

We come from politically different poles, and that’s just fine. I wouldn’t have it any other way. I believe that by our system of government, we are all endowed with the privilege of entering the voting booth and voting our best judgment and our conscience.

Therefore I give you this charge before you enter your poling place, get informed. Make an informed decision. A Time Magazine piece on Karl Barth published in the early Sixties said, “[Barth] recalls that…he advised young theologians ‘to take your Bible and take your newspaper, and read both. But interpret newspapers from your Bible.’”[16] Be informed, but let scripture inform your view of the world, not vice versa.

Be prayerful in your consideration of candidates and issues as you vote. Ask yourself “What would Jesus do?” and follow the conviction laid upon you by the Holy Spirit. This is what our Lord expects and this is how our constitution calls us to act in our vocation as citizens.

The Carroll County News says the answer to the tithe question is $70 billion. This is the traditional answer. It goes all the way back to Abram and Melchizedek in Genesis 14. Many people, including some of my seminary friends, have said, “Boy, imagine what the church could do with $70 billion?” But the question I asked was about the proper tithe, not the traditional. The Lord expects this tithe and our tithes to be more than cash.

This morning we confessed “We have been taught that to serve you is to obey you. At times fidelity to others gets in our way…We confess our mixed allegiance. Have mercy upon us as we face obligations, and reclaim us from error when we obey not your will.”[17] We make this confession again; turning away from this attitude is the proper tithe God requires. God commands that all of us, every individual one of us and the political state hear the prophet mighty in deed and word.

Again quoting Cahill, “[The Apostle Paul] is downright rabid on the subject of economic equality. He is not so unrealistic as to expect that all members of the community should have the same income, but he will have no part in treating anyone according to income. ‘In the Lord—that is, within the community of believers—everyone is to be treated equally.’”[18] The proper tithe is a turn from an attitude of self-serving economics toward justice and mercy.

This is the tithe our Lord requires. It is to trust in God’s mercy and be instruments of God’s mercy. It is to realize that we all have obligations to one another, and as we meet these obligations, as persons and as a nation, we render unto God what is God’s.

[1] Hare, Douglas R. A., Matthew: Interpretation, A Bible Commentary for Teaching and Preaching. Louisville, KY: John Know Press, 1993, page 253-4.
[2] Barth, Karl, “The Theological Declaration of Barmen” paragraph 22 found in “The Book of Confessions, The Constitution of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), Part I.” Louisville, KY: Office of the General Assembly Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), 2004, section 8.22. “Barman” was written by Karl Barth during a meeting of a group of German church leaders. When introduced it was accepted without amendment.
[3] Ibid
[4] Cahill, Thomas, “Desire of the Everlasting Hills, The World before and after Jesus.” New York: Nan A. Telese/Anchor Books, A Division of Random House, 1999, page 84.
[5] Ibid.
[6] THOMAS, Library of Congress, http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/bdquery/z?d110:HR01424:@@@L&summ2=m&#summary, retrieved October 12, 2008. Its full title is: “A bill to provide authority for the Federal Government to purchase and insure certain types of troubled assets for the purposes of providing stability to and preventing disruption in the economy and financial system and protecting taxpayers, to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to provide incentives for energy production and conservation, to extend certain expiring provisions, to provide individual income tax relief, and for other purposes.”
[7] Ibid Section 109
[8] Ibid, Section 113
[9] Stiglitz, Joseph, “Nobel Laureate: How to Get Out of the Financial Crisis.” Time.com, http://www.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,1851739,00.html?imw=Y, retrieved October 14, 2008.
[10] Thompson, Mark, Time Magazine Online, “7 Questions About the $700 Billion Bailout.”
http://www.time.com/time/politics/article/0,8599,1843941,00.html, retrieved October 14, 2008. Italics mine.
[11] Ibid, Stiglitz, http://www.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,1851739-2,00.html.
[12] Ibid Cahill, page 135, italics original in text
[13] Ibid page 42
[14] Ibid, Stiglitz, http://www.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,1851739-2,00.html.
[15] Ibid Cahill pages 91-92
[16] Time Magazine, May 31, 1963, cited from The Princeton Seminary Library, Center for Barth Studies, http://libweb.ptsem.edu/collections/barth/faq/quotes.aspx?menu=296&subText=468, retrieved October 12, 2008. The quote’s bracketed information is found that way in the website’s text.
[17] Kirk, James G., “When We Gather, A Book of Prayers for Worship, Revised Edition, For Years A, B, and C.” Louisville, KY: Geneva Press, 2001, page 119
[18] Ibid Cahill page 142, italics original in text